Life Insurance Comdex Rankings-Top 140 Rated Companies in 2023
last updated on March 22, 2024Table of contents
The Comdex score is the average ranking a company receives from the four major rating agencies in America. The four preeminent life insurance ratings that are used include: AM Best, Standard & Poor’s, Moody’s Investors Services and Fitch. A company must receive ratings from at least two of the four major rating agencies in order to receive a Comdex score.
Why use a Comdex Ranking when buying life insurance?
Since there is not a universal rating system to evaluate insurance company’s financial strength, the rating a company receives can be confusing for the consumer. For example an A+ rating with A.M. Best is the second best rating but with Standard & Poor’s or Fitch an A+ is the fifth best ranking.
Understanding the score
Rather than using letters, Comdex uses numbers on a scale of 1 to 100, with 100 being the best possible score and 1 being the lowest score. The Comdex ranking is objective and based exclusively on the calculated ratings from the four major rating agencies.
Life Insurance Comdex Rankings 2023
| Northwerstern Mutual Life Insurance Company | 100 |
| New York Life Insurance Company | 100 |
| Thrivent Financial for Lutherans | 100 |
| Guardian Life Insurance Company | 99 |
| TIAA-CREF Life Insurance Company | 99 |
| USAA Life Insurance Company | 99 |
| MassMutual Life Insurance Company | 98 |
| State Farm Life Insurance Company | 98 |
| Knights of Columbus | 98 |
| C.M. Life Insurance Company | 98 |
| MML Bay State Life Insurance Company | 98 |
| Allianz Life Insurance Company of NY | 97 |
| Sun Life & Health Insurance Company | 97 |
| Great-West Life & Annuity | 96 |
| Minnesota Life Insurance Company | 96 |
| American United Life Insurance Company | 95 |
| State Life Insurance Company | 96 |
| Western & Southern Life Insurance Company | 96 |
| Integrity Life Insurance Company | 96 |
| Lafayette Life Insurance Company | 96 |
| Columbus Life Insurance Company | 96 |
| Securian Life Insurance Company | 96 |
| National Integrity Life Ins Company of NY | 96 |
| MetLife Insurance Company | 95 |
| Prudential Life Insurance Company of America | 95 |
| Pruco Life Insurance Company | 95 |
| Pruco Life Insurance Company of NJ | 95 |
| Pacific Life Insurance Company | 95 |
| Pacific Life & Annuity Company | 95 |
| Protective Life & Annuity Insurance | 94 |
| Protective Life Insurance Company | 93 |
| Banner Life Insurance Company | 95 |
| Allianz Life Insurance Company of NA | 94 |
| William Penn Life Insurance Company of NY | 95 |
| John Hancock Life Insurance Company (USA) | 93 |
| John Hancock Life Insurance Company of NY | 93 |
| Penn Mutual Life Insurance Company | 93 |
| Primerica Life Insurance Company | 93 |
| Protective Life Insurance Company | 93 |
| West Coast Life Insurance Company | 93 |
| RiverSource Life Insurance Company | 92 |
| Great American Life Insurance Company | 92 |
| Fidelity Investments Life Insurance Company | 91 |
| Empire Fidelity Investments Life | 91 |
| American Life Insurance Company | 91 |
| Companion Life Insurance Company | 91 |
| Vantis Life Insurance Company | 91 |
| Penn Insurance & Annuity Co of NY | 91 |
| Life Insurance Company of the Southwest | 90 |
| Hartford Life & Accident Insurance | 90 |
| National Life Insurance Company | 90 |
| Principal Life Insurance Company | 90 |
| Nationwide Life Insurance Company | 90 |
| United of Omaha Life Insurance Company | 90 |
| Principal National Life Insurance Company | 90 |
| MONY Life Insurance Company | 90 |
| Midland National Life Insurance Company | 88 |
| North American Company Life & Health | 88 |
| Cincinnati Life Insurance Company | 89 |
| Reliance Standard Life Insurance Company | 91 |
| Texas Life Insurance Company | 87 |
| Liberty National Life Insurance Company | 84 |
| Globe Life & Accident Insurance Company | 83 |
| American Income Life Insurance Company (AIL) | 83 |
| United American Insurance Company | 83 |
| Lincoln National Life Insurance Company | 82 |
| Zurich American Life Insurance Company | 81 |
| Transamerica Life Insurance Company | 81 |
| Equitable Financial Life Insurance Company | 82 |
| Standard Insurance Company | 81 |
| Modern Woodmen of America | 81 |
| American General Life Insurance Company | 80 |
| United State Life Insurance Company of NY | 80 |
| Symetra Life Insurance Company | 79 |
| CMFG Life Insurance Company | 79 |
| ReliaStar Life Insurance Company | 79 |
| ReliaStar Life Insurance Company NY | 79 |
| Equitable Financial Life of America | 79 |
| Ameritas Life Insurance Corporation | 79 |
| Ameritas Life Insurance Corporation of NY | 79 |
| Dearborn National Life Insurance Company | 79 |
| Dearborn National Life Insurance Co of NY | 79 |
| Brighthouse Life Insurance Company of NY | 79 |
| Ameritas Life Insurance Corporation of NY | 79 |
| American Family Life Insurance Company WI | 78 |
| Jackson National Life Insurance Company | 76 |
| Jackson National Life Insurance Company of NY | 76 |
| Brighthouse Life Insurance Company | 76 |
| Horace Mann Life Insurance Company | 76 |
| Cigna Health & Life Insurance Company | 76 |
| American National Insurance Company | 76 |
| Mutual Trust Life Insurance Company | 75 |
| Pan-American Life Insurance Company | 75 |
| Accordia Life & Annuity Company | 75 |
| Blue Shield of CA Life & Health | 75 |
| Forethought Life Insurance Company | 75 |
| Aetna Life Insurance Company | 74 |
| Pacific Guardian Life Insurance Company | 74 |
| Unum Life Insurance Company of America | 73 |
| First Unum Life Insurance Company | 73 |
| Colonial Life & Accident Insurance | 73 |
| First Allmerica Financial Life | 75 |
| Paul Revere Life Insurance Company | 73 |
| Provident Life & Accident | 73 |
| Provident Life & Casualty | 72 |
| Americo Financial Life & Annuity | 71 |
| National Western Life Insurance Company | 71 |
| Savings Bank Mutual Life Insurance (SBLI) | 71 |
| Bankers Life & Casualty Company | 71 |
| Aetna Health & Life Insurance Company | 71 |
| USAble Life | 71 |
| Washington National Insurance Company | 71 |
| Colonial Penn Life Insurance Company | 71 |
| Ohio National Life Insurance Company (Constellation Insurance) | 70 |
| Security Life of Denver Insurance Company | 70 |
| Health Net Life Insurance Company | 69 |
| United Insurance Company of America | 61 |
| Fidelity & Guaranty Life Insurance Company | 60 |
| SBLI USA Life Insurance Company | 59 |
| Shenandoah Life Insurance Company | 59 |
| Security Benefit Life Insurance Company | 58 |
| Gleaner Life Insurance Society | 58 |
| United Heritage Life Insurance Company | 59 |
| Bankers Conseco Life Insurance Company NY | 58 |
| Union National Life Insurance Company | 58 |
| Bankers Life of Louisiana | 58 |
| Lincoln Benefit Life Co | 58 |
| Southern Financial Life Insurance Co | 58 |
| Humana Insurance Company of KY | 55 |
| ShelterPoint Life Insurance Company | 51 |
| Equitable Financial Life & Annuity | 49 |
| Union Security Insurance Company | 49 |
| Baltimore Life Insurance Company | 49 |
| Catholic Order of Foresters | 48 |
| Talcott Resolution Life Insurance Company | 47 |
| EquiTrust Life Insurance Company | 39 |
| Investors Heritage Life Insurance Company | 39 |
| ELCO Mutual Life & Annuity | 35 |
| Genworth Life Insurance Company | 32 |
| Genworth Life & Annuity Insurance Company | 32 |
Complete 2023 List of Life Insurance Ratings from A.M. Best, S&P, Moody’s and Fitch
*Ratings are subject to change
Keep Reading:
- $1 Million Life Insurance Policy
- Best Rates On A 2 Million Life Insurance Policy
- $4 Million Life Insurance Policy- Best Rates
- 35-Year Term Life Insurance Policy
- AIG Life Insurance Review
- Banner Life Insurance Review 2024
- Pacific Life Insurance Review 2024
- Primerica Life Insurance Review 2024
- Life Insurance Company Ratings 2024
- 25 Largest Life Insurance Companies 2023
- Best Life Insurance Companies That Pay Out 2024
- 54 Largest Life Insurance Stats for 2023
